Celebrating the death of Osama Bin Laden?

Whilst I would not call myself a lily-livered liberal there is still something mildly distasteful about celebrating the death of an individual, particularly in cultures which do not support the use of the death penalty, like our own in the UK. This might be seen to be also hypocritical given that we seem to be constantly at war with one regime or another, and also given our thinly veiled objective of trying to “de-capitate” Libya – all of which reinforces the general acceptance that killing people can be justified. However ask someone to vote on it, and they will vote against.

The news this morning about the death of Bin Laden showed a spontaneous street celebration in New York’s Time Square ( must have been at least 50 people!) giving “high fives”, chanting “USA, USA” and even “passing round beer” – whatever next? As day breaks then perhaps more will flood into the Square to celebrate….well, celebrate what, exactly? The end of an era? The end of terrorism? The perpetrator of 9/11? The rather worrying thing is that this not the end of anything – this could be the start of something a lot worse. Some of the world’s great religions started on the back of their charismatic leader being executed. Have the Americans not heard of martyrdom – why do they think there are suicide bombings?

The picture of the dead Bin Laden, could be anyone, and unless there is irrefutable proof that it is him, this could continue as a “conspiracy theory” for years. It is reported that Bin Laden was given the option to surrender…before they shot him, as well as supposedly filming him. This will be on the internet before the year is out – in much the same way as the hanging of Saddam. Whilst it might be gruesome, it is the only way to quash unnecessary rumours.

It is not surprising that America is now on alert. As the “celebrations” die down this heightened level of anxiety will pervade the Western world and re-establish group-paranoia.

Mr Obama ordered the “rolling of the dice” over the last few days, and “rolled a 6” – time will tell whether that’s “good luck” or “bad luck”!

Categories: Uncategorized

Tags: , , , , , ,

1 reply

  1. I’m glad I found your blog. I am an American and I do not share the apparent celebratory mood of most of my fellow Americans. Indeed, I am appalled at the merriment that is being scattered across the media and internet. I think that Bin Laden was probably a very dangerous criminal, and if he truly was the mastermind of 9/11, then I think he deserved very severe punishment. But, had he been captured, imprisoned for life and interrogated, America would have been in a position to learn more about terroristic organizations. We could have learned how to better defend ourselves. Instead, a body was dumped at sea, supposedly with all the rituals required of Islam. At least, that is the story we have been given. Why was a body so hastily dumped? Was it really Bin Laden’s body? Why wasn’t the world given more proof of identity other than relying on the word of the U.S. Government? I am an American citizen, and I love my country, but the government has always lied to us about affairs of state. They have always lied and they will continue to lie, as they wish to protect the secrets that give all the power and privilege to the wealthy elite class. We are more a plutocracy than a democracy. The United States has a long history steeped in telling lies to the American citizens and to the world abroad. I suppose it is the way of the world for governments and rulers to lie to their citizens and subjects. But, we don’t have to believe it. I learned some time ago that almost every historical and political fact that I was taught in the American education system was a mixture of lies, fables, and half-truths. The higher education system is not much better, as I earned my B.S. from an American university; and, years later, I’m still unraveling myths and lies. I just thought you may appreciate the viewpoint of one American who actually relies on critical thinking to form my opinions.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: